Tuesday, February 07, 2006

Cause and Effect

"Bring out your dead! Bring out your dead!"
"But I'm not dead yet!"
THUD

Remember that classic scene in the Monty Python's Holy Grail where cause and effect get a little intertwined? Well it seems like a similar sort of confusion seems to be bringing us closer and closer to a dangerous religious world war.

I was raised Catholic and studied the Bible like a good European intellectual, but lost my last bit of my faith somewhere around the time I studied the story of Job, and realized that, unless you happened to be Job and not the thousands of people who died pointless and painful deaths so that Job could learn a lesson (and God could win a gambling bet with Satan), the Bible didn't make much sense. It's all fine and dandy if you are suffering because God is testing your faith; it's another thing to be burned alive with your kids because God is testing the faith of Joe Schmoe down the street. But I digress...

Religion can be opium to the masses, as the cliche goes. (It also appears that it can be more like amphetamines- if you look at what's going on in extremist regious sects around the world.) In educated agnostic America, we have generally looked onto various religions with a distance but respect, like we give people who walk on the sidewalk without stepping on any of the cracks. You can think whatever you want as long as you don't bother me; I'm sure I have my own superstitions. However, the events around the world in the last 8 years and the parallel rise in relgious fundamentalism and extremism, should probably cause us to reconsider that lack of concern.

As many religion and world politics experts are beginning to publicize, there is a growing mass of Americans who have taken those popular apocalyptic Left Behind thrillers seriously and believe that the end of the world is upon us (an AP poll conducted in 1997 -before the books came out- found that 24% of Americans believe that these events will take place during their lifetimes). However giddy they may be about their soon-to-be "rapture" (and everyone else's fire and brimestone ending - good Christians, as they are, they seem to be unusually giddy about this, too), they still take the Bible "literally" and await the fulfillment of several prophecies that have to occur before the coming of Armageddon. And this is where the rest of us should start to worry...

As the conservative publication, The National Review revealed a few years ago, certain events (such as a great war against Islam in Israel and the birth of a rare red heifer) must occur in order for the second coming to occur. And as the article further points out, even devout Christians aren't leaving these events to chance. A red heifer has been recently born in Israel, though not without the help of a special breeding program set up by Texas fundamentalist Christians. And the tensions between Islam and Christianity continue to grow, though again, one could question whether the angry protests seen around the world today would have been possible without an internationally opposed invasion of Iraq by a president who likened the war to the Crusades.

And so here we are. Scientists, nurses, business owners, college students: going about their daily lives, disappointed and frustrated with the policies of this country, but waiting for the next round of elections to balance things out again. We are surprised when the conservatives win another round at the polls, after "motivating the church going folk" -- but maybe we shouldn't be. Maybe we should realize the destructive power people are capable of wielding when they actually believe that the end of the world is near. They're not too concerned about their gas milage, global warming, or even human rights; but don't take kindly to having their faith threatened or their power usurped.

In the last week, many of us have been surprised by the irrationality, passion and anger displayed by Muslims around the world in response to the now infamous cartoons. Don't they realize that they are being manipulated by extremists? How can they even honestly be upset when cartoons like this against Judism and Christianity are published in their papers regularly? But that is rational thinking, and when it comes to religion, there is less and less room for reason. As religious tensions rise and extermist view points continue to influence politics around the world, the rest of us are waking up to a frightening new reality: a reversal of the cause and effect paradigm, where religious people are so convinced of their own beliefs that they are willing to do anything to make them real.

9 comments:

MJ said...

WOW. I've NEVER heard it put like that before! I would expect nothing less from you, my old friend. Great argument, with implied conclusions the potentially terrifying extent of which you have left the reader room to surmise. Wonderful piece of writing!

Joe said...

MJ pointed me in this direction and I'm glad she did. This is a brilliant analysis.

Your points about the second coming are especailly interesting when we consider that the belief amongst many Jews in Jesus' time was that the end of time was upon them. Put in that context, the teachings - and the firestorm they created, is somewhat parallel to the current mind set of some fundamentalists. It'll be interesting to see how this plays out.

Wadena said...

I loved the opium/amphetamines variation....that was excellent.

This though....

"""How can they even honestly be upset when cartoons like this against Judism and Christianity are published in their papers regularly?"""

Here's the thing: They are upset because one is NOT allowed to draw or carve an image of Mohammed in their religion.

To do so is to flush the Koran down a toilet.

That's the issue, not satire.

Christianity ALLOWS anyone to carve or draw images of Christ and God....we do it all the time and sometimes satirically.

In fact, such cartoons are common in our newspapers, so why not theirs?

But drawing an image of Mohammed is forbidden to a Muslim....and for us to do what is forbidden to them is simply over the top.

Now I must go search and see if there is a blog called "The Red Heifer."

I invite you to comment on what I wrote today over on my blog.

I questioned the people who say that religion causes war and I'd be honored if you would take a look.

Wadena said...

Wadena adds:

Of course, there is a "Red Heifer" blog......kind of disappointing.

They just use it to plug the book of that name and it's not well-done.

That name has marketing potential.

Red Heifer perfume commercial....

"I don't know what came over me that night....it must have been the bewitching scent of her....Red Heifer."

This is all your fault....you brought it up.

:)

hibiscusfire said...

Wadena,

I don't actually think religion causes war (one hand clapping and all), but I do think that relgion has historically been used to manipulate people into war. Most relgions in the world are supposedly nonviolent; yet most men go williingly into battle believing that god is on their side.

hibiscusfire said...

Also, just a thought:

From my elementary understanding of the Koran, I would also think that to decapitate an unarmed civilian on national TV in the name of Mohammed is also a kin to flushing the Koran down the toilet.

yet no one seems to be burning buildings over that...

Wadena said...

I'm hoping to blog on Just War Principles soon.

So far, I'm thinking that America is probably in violation of most or all of the traditional Just War doctrines, and those Middle East folks we have attacked are NOT in violation of those doctrines.

I'm reading Jimmy Carter's latest book and pondering his rather conservative viewpoint on Just War. He's being very polite in the face of Bush war crimes.

It is probably difficult for Americans to see the war from the Muslim point of view and impossible for Americans to understand the Muslim's cultural attitudes toward the concepts of civilian and non-civilian and unconventional warfare.

I think those we have attacked in the Middle East see everybody as being in the war and Americans would rather pretend that only soldiers are in the war and those soldiers aren't killing babies and other innocents.

When reality intrudes on that view, Americans seem to want to pretend that, IF they do kill civilians it's just a tragic mistake (recent Predator murders require a deeper form of denial but there appears to be no limit to that depth).

Muslims are understandably unimpressed by this American foray into fantasy, as am I.

My limited understanding of the Koran indicates that when you are attacked--you show no mercy until you have won the war.

I think we can expect no mercy until we ask for peace and forgiveness and stop meddling in the Middle East.

hibiscusfire said...

Really, I see no difference between flying an airplane into a building, dropping "precision" bombs onto homes in an airstrike to "shock and awe", or setting off a roadside bomb in the middle of a wedding.

Your statement: "I think those we have attacked in the Middle East see everybody as being in the war and Americans would rather pretend that only soldiers are in the war and those soldiers aren't killing babies and other innocents."
could easily be reversed to explain the viewpoint of many Americans who believe that all Muslims can be held responsible for 9/11. Both are the type of idiotic viewpoints that let Joe or Omar decide for themselves that they know what "just war" is.

If it is true that the Koran says that "if you are attacked, you show now mercy" then Afghanies should be pretty grateful that Americans didn't follow Muslim law and just drop a nuclear weapon on the whole country. But again, I doubt that that is what the Koran says, or Iran and Iraq would have blown each other up years ago. Same for the Sunnis and Shiites.

I don't know of a easy solution to the mess our government has added to in Iraq. However, I don't think we are the only ones responsible and it wasn't so wonderful before we got there. (I'm not saying it justifies going in, I'm just saying that we can't be blamed for everything that is happening over there)

When I see millions of Muslims get more passionate over a visual insult of their prophet than they do over how their prophet's name is used as an excuse to bomb, torture or oppress other Muslims, I hardly see a bright future ahead for that land.

Who do we ask forgiveness of? The men who bomb kids so that they can regain power and oppress their neighbors? Should we leave the average Iraqi in their hands? That seems rather irresponsible.

Obviously, this is a complicated issue.

Wadena said...

I think you are in a place where further discussion with me probably will not be fruitful......but I'll give it one more shot.

You seem to want to find everybody at fault in this matter.

But.....the first aggressor must offer peace and make amends.

Otherwise the war will continue.